Book Review: Magpie Lane by Lucy Atkins

Book Review: Magpie Lane by Lucy Atkins


When the eight-year-old daughter of an Oxford College Master vanishes in the middle of the night, police turn to the Scottish nanny, Dee, for answers.

As Dee looks back over her time in the Master’s Lodging – an eerie and ancient house – a picture of a high achieving but dysfunctional family emerges: Nick, the fiercely intelligent and powerful father; his beautiful Danish wife Mariah, pregnant with their child; and the lost little girl, Felicity, almost mute, seeing ghosts, grieving her dead mother.

But is Dee telling the whole story? Is her growing friendship with the eccentric house historian, Linklater, any cause for concern? And most of all, why is Felicity silent?

My Review:

Magpie Lane was such a lush book to get lost in! I wouldn’t necessarily call it atmospheric, but the Oxford setting, the old master’s house and the scholarly college vibes made for a very immersive reading experience. I love when a book gives you the chance to see a behind-closed-doors look at the lives of posh people, and Magpie Lane delivered that. Nick and Mariah are those type of people that seem to have it all together, but only the parts that they let people see. I loved getting to see how much they dropped the ball on while trying to project a much more elevated front.

One thing that was a little hard for me was the timeline and overall format. The novel is almost like a collection of stories about the nanny’s time with the family, all told in response to questions the detectives are asking her, in their efforts to find Felicity. For the most part, the stories go in order but I felt the lines between past and present were a little muddled. Someone like me likes nice headings that tell the when and where, but this is something that might not bother most people.

I really was guessing until the end. I had a lot of theories, and one of them did turn out to be right, but I wasn’t sure until the end. I felt like this was a slow burn of a thriller, but I really did enjoy it overall. There weren’t too many characters, which is good, yet they all had their own shadowy history, so you really don’t know who to root for! A little on the cozy side, this would make a good fall or winter mystery!